I respect your point of view Maj, but i think that we are not talking about the same issue. Im not talking about combomakers competition ( if not, would not make much sense to propose a more discreet exchange of ideas between combomakers ... Just do not post anything,and problem solved ).
Maj wrote:Um, i don't think it's that big of an issue. If your video is going to be released in a week or two, then you can just wait until it's finished to tell people about your combo ideas.
Well, if I wait to finish ( and to publish) a vid, isnt it a bit unnecessary to explain what you can already see? Maybe you can explain something like "here I use a super jump cancel" if somebody asks what happen just in that second, but nothing more.And you can also do it simply in the youtube s channel... In this case there is no exchange of information between combomakers, there is exchange of information with the word, because the video is already published.
Precisely that might be, in my opinion, one of the advantages of belonging to SonicHurricane community, is to exchange ideas and ways to searching without having to wait for publication of the videos ... Otherwise, we could not differentiate too much this forum from other forums that simply post combo vids and then talk about the combo stuff inside.
Maj wrote:
On the other hand, if your video is going to take four months to finish, then you can't really expect your combos to remain secret that whole time. If someone else finds them first, there's nothing you can do about it. I don't think this forum can prevent that from happening, and i don't think this forum should prevent that. Combo making will always be a little competitive, even if we're all friends.
Mmm I dont want this forum give me to me some "magic" protection to prevent that someone, in his house, will find something before me, this is actually ridiculous, yeah.You say "i don't think this forum
should prevent that" but the true is that this forum
cannot prevent that, nothing can prevent it. If someone finds something cool before me, fantastic, I will congratulate him on the discovery and will try to learn something from that. And if I already had found it but he also published before... Bad luck for me, no problem.
I was not talking about this case, I was talking to someone
outside our forum read our progress in a particular game engine, and without contributing in anything, simply record a fast guetto clip. I do not think that is the same as finding something for yourself ...
Maj wrote:
Besides, i don't think anyone deserves credit for anything that's found in the first 2-3 months after a new game is released. If you find something in the first two weeks, it's ridiculous to claim that the world couldn't find it if you didn't exist.
Maybe if you find a new combo two years later, then you can say it's "your" combo. But i don't think anyone deserves to be known for anything that's going on in MvC3 right now. Does anyone remember who figured out how to combo after Guile's Flash Kick super in MvC2? Or AHVB x3? Or s.HK xx AHVB?
Again, the "combo credits" are not the problem for me. Is not something I care too much. In fact, I think as Combonauts, we have not discovered anything, hehehe ...
But I like to think that Sonic Hurricane can function as a small working group, and we can help each other. If Dooplis, error1, onreload, Snoooootch, or any combomaker of this forum want to make a nice CMV and i can help him with something, like test, give an opinion, suggest, or whether they can draw on something that we have discovered, great then, i dont have any problem with this, on the contrary, I feel great to help this forum and to help to become good CMVs.
But the idea of make the "hard work" for someone that only enter here to try to read something he can burn quickly and meanly to get some fast views... dont like me so much.
It was just that, nothing else. Surely I will have explained bad, sorry if you wasted your time, it's really a nonsense.